Prince Street Pizza

- 680 S Mill Ave #102, Tempe, AZ 85281

For pizza enthusiasts in the greater Phoenix area and especially around the Arizona State University (ASU) campus, the arrival of Prince Street Pizza in Tempe represents a major culinary event. This establishment is not just another pizza joint; it is the Arizona outpost of a globally recognized New York City institution, famous for its distinctive and highly sought-after style of pizza. Located directly on the bustling Mill Avenue, Prince Street Pizza brings its legendary Sicilian “SoHo” Squares and authentic Neapolitan round pies to the desert, offering locals an unparalleled taste of East Coast pizza culture.

The core philosophy of this restaurant is simple yet profound: "if you can put it on pasta you can put it on pizza." This guides their creative menu, which features an exciting variety of both thick-crusted, airy square pies (the Sicilian style) and traditional, thin-crusted round pies (the Neapolitan style). Their commitment to authenticity means using time-honored family recipes and preparing their handcrafted sauces daily from scratch.

The experience is designed to be vibrant, mirroring the energy of a classic New York slice shop while catering to the dynamic needs of the Tempe community, including late-night food cravings and diverse dietary preferences. Whether you’re a student, a local family, or a visitor, Prince Street Pizza offers a unique, high-quality pizza experience that stands out in the Arizona dining landscape.

Prince Street Pizza is perfectly positioned in the CenterPoint on Mill Avenue, placing it at the epicenter of Tempe’s shopping, dining, and nightlife district, just steps from the ASU campus. This location is easily accessible for pedestrians and those using public transit, making it a convenient stop for a quick lunch or a late-night bite.

The full street address is:

680 S Mill Ave #102, Tempe, AZ 85281, USA

Given its downtown location, parking options are typical for the area and include:

• Paid parking garage
• Paid street parking

Patrons should be aware of parking fees and availability, especially during peak hours. The restaurant welcomes well-behaved pets with a "Dogs allowed" policy, extending to both the inside and outside seating areas, a great amenity for Arizona pet owners enjoying a walk on Mill Ave.

Prince Street Pizza offers multiple convenient options to ensure everyone in the Arizona community can enjoy their iconic pies:

• Takeout: Ideal for customers who prefer to pick up their order quickly and enjoy it elsewhere.
• Delivery: Available for those within the delivery radius, bringing the authentic New York slice experience right to your door.
• No-contact delivery: An essential option for guests prioritizing safety and convenience.
• Curbside Pickup: Offers a quick and easy way to receive your order without leaving your vehicle.
• Counter Service: True to its New York slice shop roots, allowing for quick, single-slice purchases.
• Seating: Available for patrons who wish to dine-in and soak up the cool vibe of the location, including outdoor options as indicated by customer reviews.
• Catering: A fantastic option for large gatherings, office lunches, or student events, allowing for big orders of their famous square and round pies.
• Dining Options: Serves meals throughout the day, specializing in Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.

What makes Prince Street Pizza a must-try destination in Arizona is its range of distinctive products and welcoming atmosphere:

• Iconic Sicilian Square Pies: The restaurant is nationally famous for its thick, crispy-bottomed, yet airy Sicilian squares, such as the widely praised Spicy Spring Pie (featuring Fra Diavolo Sauce and signature pepperoni cups) and The Naughty Pie (with Spicy Vodka Sauce, pepperoni, ricotta, and a drizzle of Zab's Hot Honey).
• Diverse Pizza Styles: In addition to the famous square pies ("12 X 17"), they offer classic 18-inch Round Pies (Neapolitan style) and 10-inch Pizzettas for personal servings, ensuring a crust and size for every preference.
• Late-Night Food: A vital feature for the ASU community and downtown nightlife patrons, offering delicious food during late hours.
• Comprehensive Dietary Options: The menu thoughtfully includes numerous options for all dietary needs, offering delicious Vegan options (like the Vegan Pie and the Vegan Gluten-Free Personal Sicilian) and Vegetarian options, alongside a range of meat and cheese-centric pies.
• Gluten-Free Sicilian: A dedicated menu section for personal-sized (2 slices) Gluten-Free Sicilian pies, allowing those with sensitivities to enjoy the signature style (note: the restaurant advises that products are prepared in facilities where gluten is present).
• Family-Friendly Environment: The venue is explicitly listed as Family-friendly and Good for kids, making it a great destination for a casual family meal. It is also listed as LGBTQ+ friendly.
• Specialty Sides and Desserts: Beyond pizza, the menu features delicious Italian-inspired sides like Arancini and Smoked Mozzarella Sticks, and an impressive lineup of authentic New York-style desserts including NY Cheesecake (Actually Made In NY), Tiramisu, and Italian Rainbow Cake.

For Arizonans looking to get in touch, place an order, or inquire about catering, the contact details for the Tempe location are readily available:

Address: 680 S Mill Ave #102, Tempe, AZ 85281, USA

Phone: (480) 389-3951

Mobile Phone: +1 480-389-3951

The establishment accepts various payment methods for customer convenience, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Arizonans should choose Prince Street Pizza when they desire an elevated, authentic pizza experience that goes beyond standard local fare. The primary draw is the opportunity to taste the internationally acclaimed Sicilian square pizza—a style known for its perfect balance of a light, focaccia-like crust and a deeply satisfying crunch at the base. Signature pies like the Spicy Spring are widely regarded as a best-in-class product, a culinary achievement well worth seeking out.

Beyond the quality of the food, the Tempe location offers practical advantages for the local user. The Mill Avenue location is unparalleled for convenience, especially for those in the downtown area or on the ASU campus. The comprehensive service options—including no-contact delivery and curbside pickup—cater to a fast-paced lifestyle, while the seating, though possibly limited, provides a great atmosphere for a dine-in experience.

Furthermore, the menu’s extensive commitment to inclusivity, featuring high-quality Vegan and Gluten-Free Sicilian options, ensures that guests with specific dietary needs do not have to compromise on enjoying a top-tier pizza. Whether you are craving the comfort food of a Meat Lovers square, the unique spice of a pizza topped with Hot Honey, or a personal-sized Pizzetta for lunch, Prince Street Pizza delivers an authentic slice of New York City right here in Tempe, Arizona, making it an essential addition to the local pizza rotation.

Prince Street Pizza

680 S Mill Ave #102, Tempe, AZ 85281, USA